I have to admit I checked this book out with some trepidation. Books like this tend to fall one of two ways. They either totally whitewash what happened or they blame the white men and make it look like we were trying to kill everyone. I was worried this was going to be one of the latter.
But, quite thankfully it wasn’t. It did a really good job talking about building the transcontinental railroad and how the white men were unfair to the Chinese who came over. They talked about the challenges the workers faced and how hard it was. It wasn’t whitewashed, but it also wasn’t done to put blame, just done factually in a good story.
So, what’d we do to follow this up?
First they drew pictures of what happened in the story.
That’s when I discovered that Iron Man went back in time to protect the workers on the railroad. Little known fact.
Then we cut out little triangles to glue on the people’s heads for their coolie hats.
Here’s their summaries:
Batman: Iron Man came back and fought the monsters that caused the avalanche and then he dug the guy out of the snow so he wouldn’t freeze. Then they built a train. (This is my best recall because he wouldn’t let me write it down because he said he already had, see the letters on the top left).
Superman: There was a monster biting the boy when he was covered in the snow. Then a big monster came and bit the guys up on top. Another guy tried to look for him, but the monster kept eating him. They were trying to build snow piles. (Superman’s is the one with the blue railroad and brown dirt)
Princess: They were building a tent and a train. A monster came and stole the little boy.
Princess’ is the one on the right in the middle picture. Hers is the big tall pink one. Next to this you can see the other side of Batman’s. They had a lot of fun creating these. It really cracked me up.
So, as you can tell they were much more interested in the stories they’d created than in necessarily retelling what happened in the story. But I wrote it down because someday I want to be able to tell them how all the stories they made up had monsters.
For more great art and story ideas head on over to A Mommy’s Adventures to see what everyone else is doing this week.
Oh, and if you’re so inclined say a prayer for my family and Tara today. This is Sam’s birthday, and it will be the first one since he died. We’re “celebrating” by watching Star Wars in his honor (Return of the Jedi, probably the most kid friendly of the original movies).
Wonder Mom says
I think I saw an “Iron Man” reference in Wickipedia the other day when researching the Transcontinental Railroad- I am so glad he was there to help the less fortunate… ;0)
P.S. Y'all will be in my prayers today…
Hee hee iron man. I will say a prayer for you guys and Sam's family.
Their pictures are interesting. I think it's great how you are remembering Sam and supporting Tara.
I always love reading your posts…Iron Man is too cute and the pictures look great too! Thank you for linking to stART :0)
I will be keeping you and Sam's Family in my prayers.
An Almost Unschooling Mom says
I didn't realize monsters were such a problem for the railroad workers – good to know.
And yes, certainly we'll pray. I hope you really enjoy memories of Sam, while you watch the movies together.
I just love how your kids turn everything into monsters!
You and Tara are in my prayers today!
Joyful Learner says
Love their drawings and writing! JC is really into monsters right now too. I wonder if it's developmental?
Prayers lifted up for your friend Tara and her family.
Raising a Happy Child says
I kept reading the stories and looking back at the Amazon summary. Your kids have such vivid imaginations. So is Superman an artist and Batman is the puzzle master? I loved all the pictures.
I also will be praying.
So glad Ironman was there to help. Silly interfering monsters.
JDaniel4's Mom says
This sounds like a wonderful book. My post is going up tonight. Please stop by.
Valerie @ Frugal Family Fun Blog says
I'll be keeping your family and Tara in my prayers. I love how you recorded each of their versions of the story and how creative they were at making up their own stories!
I love that Iron Man went back in time to help. I think we will have to check out this book as we work through the Western States.
Christianne @ Little Page Turners says
Great project! (Hope the evening went well.)